EEA Advisory

Chattel Mortgage or Novated Lease for a Business Car?

EEA Advisory

15 November 2026 · 14 min read

Share

Choosing between a chattel mortgage and a novated lease comes down to who needs to own the vehicle and how the costs will be paid. A chattel mortgage suits businesses and ABN holders wanting ownership and control from day one. A novated lease suits employees using salary packaging through their employer. This guide breaks down tax treatment, GST, running costs and end of term outcomes.

Featured image for Chattel Mortgage or Novated Lease for a Business Car?

Buying or packaging a car through your business often comes down to one decision. Do you need the business to own the vehicle from day one or are you an employee who can package the cost through salary sacrifice. If you need ownership and asset control a chattel mortgage fits. If you are an employee whose employer offers salary packaging and you want bundled running costs a novated lease fits. Everything else follows from that starting point.

Chattel mortgage vs novated lease at a glance

FactorChattel mortgageNovated lease
Core arrangementBusiness loan secured on the vehicleThree way lease between employee employer and financier
Vehicle owner during termBorrower owns the car while lender holds securityFinancier owns the car while employee drives it
Who it suitsBusinesses and ABN holders wanting ownershipEmployees whose employer offers salary packaging
Cash flow pathRepayments leave business bank accountRepayments deducted from pre tax salary
GST handlingBusiness often claims credit on purchase subject to rulesEmployer claims GST on lease then adjusts through salary packaging
Primary tax focusDepreciation interest business use recordsSalary sacrifice fringe benefits tax operating cost or statutory method
Running cost handlingBusiness pays costs as they arise or arranges a fleet cardCosts can be bundled into the lease budget for predictable deductions
End of termBusiness owns vehicle outright once loan and balloon repaidEmployee may pay residual extend lease or return vehicle

What is a chattel mortgage

A chattel mortgage is a business car loan in which the vehicle acts as security. The borrower takes legal title to the car on settlement and the financier registers its interest on the national Personal Property Securities Register. Repayments cover principal and interest and a balloon can be set to lower those regular instalments. That balloon is a lump sum that falls due at the end of the term. Because the business owns the asset it places the car on its balance sheet and starts claiming depreciation under Division 40 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997. Interest on the loan is generally deductible to the extent the vehicle is used for business. A GST registered entity may claim an input tax credit on the vehicle price up to the relevant car limit. Accurate logbook records are vital when the car also sees private trips because deductions must reflect the actual business percentage.

The loan resembles many other secured facilities. You can choose term deposit rate and balloon level, refinance the balloon or pay it out from trading cash. Early payout usually attracts break fees that the contract discloses. Because the business owns the vehicle it controls colours options accessories signage tow bars trays and resale timing. If a ute needs a service body or a van needs shelving the lender will not object provided the security interest remains protected. That ownership also means the business bears resale risk. If market prices fall the borrower cannot hand the car back without clearing the debt.

What is a novated lease

A novated lease is a set of two linked contracts. First an employee signs a vehicle lease with a financier. Second the employee novates or transfers the lease obligations to the employer. The employer then deducts rental payments and often running costs from the employee salary before tax. The tripartite nature gives the arrangement its flexibility. When the employee stays, the employer makes payments. If the employee changes jobs the lease can move to a new employer or revert to the employee personally.

The financier remains the legal owner during the lease. The arrangement commonly runs for two to five years and includes a residual value that must meet ATO minimum percentages. That residual keeps the periodic rentals lower while reflecting expected market value at lease end. The employee may then purchase the car for the residual, refinance it or hand the vehicle back to the financier for sale. Fringe benefits tax applies because the employer is providing a car benefit. Employers usually choose the statutory formula unless the operating cost method with logbooks yields a lower taxable value. Many packages bundle registration insurance servicing tyres fuel and roadside assistance into a budgeted annual amount. Each pay cycle the employee sees a pre tax deduction for most of that amount, sometimes topped up by a small post tax contribution that reduces FBT.

Because payments are salary sacrificed the employee reduces taxable income today rather than waiting for an end of year deduction. That appeals to higher marginal rate earners who also value cost predictability. The car never appears on the business balance sheet. Instead it sits on the financier ledger and the employer only accounts for payments and FBT.

Eligibility explained for sole traders company directors and employees

A sole trader is the legal entity carrying on the business. That trader cannot employ themselves in the ordinary sense required for novation. For that reason novated leases rarely if ever suit sole traders. A business car loan or chattel mortgage almost always replaces the concept of salary packaging when the ABN holder drives the car.

A company director sits in a different position. If the company pays that director a wage and offers salary packaging the director can in theory enter a novated lease with a financier, then novate it to the company. The structure passes the employer test though auditors will want to confirm that the wage is genuine and that related party benefits are documented at arm’s length. When a director instead receives only dividends a novated lease is unavailable because no employer-employee relationship exists.

An ordinary employee without an ownership stake in the employer faces the simplest eligibility path. If the employer maintains a salary packaging policy and a provider portal the employee can choose the vehicle age price and accessories within policy limits. If the employer does not support novated leasing the employee must look to a personal loan or car subscription because a company cannot be compelled to novate.

Tax and GST comparison

Tax outcomes depend on business use, vehicle type, purchase price and personal income. Under a chattel mortgage the business claims depreciation on the car’s cost base up to the luxury car limit for conventional vehicles or the higher fuel efficient limit for qualifying low emission cars. Temporary full expensing ended in June 2023 but small business entities can still access the instant asset write off for eligible purchases below the legislated threshold, subject to annual updates. Interest on the loan is deductible according to the business use percentage established by a logbook or other reasonable method under Division 28. GST can often be claimed upfront on the purchase invoice again limited by the car caps. Subsequent running costs then carry no GST credit because the credit was already captured on full price unless the business chooses to claim credits on each cost and adjust for the actual credit at the end of the first tax period.

Under a novated lease the employer claims GST on the lease rentals and bundled costs. The employer then passes the GST exclusive amount to the employee packaged from salary. GST savings therefore flow indirectly to the employee through lower payroll deductions rather than through the personal tax return. Fringe benefits tax arises unless exempt. From 1 July 2022 eligible zero emission vehicles below the luxury car threshold are exempt from FBT when provided to employees, creating a strong incentive to package an electric car through novation. The exemption does not apply to plug in hybrids purchased after 1 April 2025 unless a financial commitment exists before that date. For internal combustion vehicles the statutory formula calculates FBT as twenty percent of the purchase price irrespective of kilometres unless the operating cost method and logbook show a lower taxable value. Employees often make a small after tax contribution to reduce the reportable fringe benefit amount which in turn minimises Medicare levy surcharge and other means tested impacts.

Ownership balance sheet and control

Ownership determines who controls upgrades insurance policies colours and resale strategy. With a chattel mortgage the business owns the VIN from settlement. The car appears as a depreciating asset and the loan appears under liabilities. Lenders may impose insurance requirements naming them as interested party but otherwise the business chooses sum insured and repairer. If market timing looks favourable the business may sell the car before the loan term ends and discharge the remaining balance, subject to a potential break cost. That flexibility suits trades and services that modify utes vans and trucks or rack up high kilometres and need frequent replacement.

With a novated lease the financier keeps title and sets end of lease options. The employee cannot sell the car privately unless they first pay out the residual or refinance. Modifications that materially alter resale value usually require the lessor’s consent. The asset never inflates the business balance sheet. That matters for metrics such as return on assets or lending covenants where extraneous vehicles can distort ratios.

Running costs and administration

Running a vehicle involves more than finance. Registration insurance tyres wiper blades fuel charging cables tolls and roadside assistance all chew time and cash. Under a chattel mortgage the business carries those costs as they fall due or sets up fleet cards for consistent reporting. Good bookkeeping software can code each expense to motor vehicle with GST captured at point of payment. Service scheduling and tyre replacement remain internal tasks unless outsourced.

Novated leasing shines on administration. Many providers wrap running costs into a single budget and issue a fuel card or electric charging subscription. Each pay cycle the provider sweeps funds from the employer and tops up the budget. When the employee pays for a service the card deducts the amount and reconciles with the budget. The employee therefore sees one figure on the payslip rather than irregular invoices. The trade off is that packaged costs carry management fees and conservative buffers to avoid shortfalls. Careful drivers sometimes finish the year with surplus budget that either reduces next year payments or returns after reconciliation.

What happens at the end

A chattel mortgage ends when the borrower makes the final repayment and, if present, clears the balloon. The lender then releases its PPSR registration and sends a discharge document. The business now owns the car unencumbered. It can keep the vehicle, trade it in or sell it privately. If the balloon feels heavy the borrower can refinance it into a new chattel mortgage or small business loan subject to credit approval. Any sale proceeds above written down value create a balancing adjustment income. Below written down value they create a deduction.

A novated lease ends when the agreed term expires and the residual triggers. The employee can pay the residual and take title, refinance the residual into a personal loan or lease, extend the lease or in some cases hand the car back to the financier. Handback terms depend on the contract and vehicle condition. Excess kilometres or poor condition often attract charges that erode the benefit of returning the car. If the employee changes jobs before term end the lease must be transferred to the new employer or revert to a personal arrangement. Some employers allow an early exit where the employee takes the car and assumes payments, though that normally forfeits any employer contribution still to be made.

Worked examples

ScenarioSole trader work uteCompany director mixed use SUVEmployee salary packaging hatch
Vehicle price including GST60,00075,00042,000
Deposit6,00000
Term in years554
Interest or lease rate8 percent8 percent9 percent lease rate
Balloon or residual12,00022,50013,440 residual at 32 percent
Business use percentage8060N A salary packaging
Annual kilometres25,00020,00015,000
Annual running cost budget8,9009,5007,800 maintained
Estimated after tax cash flow per year14,10018,6009,950 via salary sacrifice

Figures are illustrative based on average small business and packaging assumptions current at November 2026, excluding stamp duty variations and individual tax offsets.

The sole trader claims eighty percent of depreciation and interest, plus GST credits, reducing taxable income each year. The director’s company uses the logbook to claim sixty percent of depreciation and interest, then may top up the director’s reportable fringe benefits item to account for private use. The employee sacrifices part of the salary but pays no FBT thanks to an electric hatch that falls under the current exemption limits.

Making the choice

Decision making starts with eligibility. If you have an ABN and want your business to own a vehicle from day one you gravitate toward a chattel mortgage. If you receive wages and your employer offers salary packaging explore novated leasing. After clearing that hurdle compare total contract cost rather than weekly repayment. Check interest or lease rate, fees, balloon or residual, GST credits, tax deductions, FBT impact, running cost budgets and resale risk. A chattel mortgage suits asset control and modification. A novated lease suits predictable budgeting and personal tax smoothing. Both structures can work poorly when misunderstood. Always test figures through calculators then confirm with your accountant.

Questions to ask before signing

Who will own the car during the agreement. What is the balloon or residual amount and how will you pay it. What fees apply on application monthly and at payout. Which running costs are included and which remain your responsibility. How is GST handled within repayments or up front. What happens if the car is written off or stolen. What happens if employment ends during a novated lease. What records must be kept for tax purposes. How soon can the agreement be refinanced or settled. Will the quoted repayment rise if interest rates move.

FAQs

Is a chattel mortgage or novated lease better for a business car

Neither structure is automatically better. A chattel mortgage is designed for a business to buy and own a vehicle. A novated lease is an employee salary packaging arrangement involving an employer.

Can a sole trader get a novated lease

A sole trader generally cannot because the arrangement requires an employer and an employee as separate parties. A chattel mortgage or other business finance usually replaces novation for sole traders.

Can a company director use a novated lease

Yes when the company genuinely employs the director and offers salary packaging. The director must receive wages not just dividends and the arrangement should be documented at market value.

Who owns the car under a chattel mortgage

The business owns the vehicle from settlement while the lender holds a security interest until the loan is fully repaid.

Who owns the car under a novated lease

The financier owns the vehicle during the lease. The employee gains the right to use it under the novated arrangement.

Can a business claim GST on a chattel mortgage

A GST registered business can usually claim an input tax credit on the purchase price up to the relevant car limit. The credit must reflect business use if the car is also used privately.

Does a novated lease avoid tax

A novated lease does not avoid tax. It changes how vehicle costs are funded through salary sacrifice and how FBT applies. Overall tax outcomes depend on personal circumstances.

Is a balloon payment the same as a novated lease residual

Both create a final lump sum but they come from different structures. A balloon belongs to a loan while a residual belongs to a lease.

What happens if an employee changes jobs

The lease can move to a new employer, revert to the employee personally or sometimes be terminated. The outcome depends on the novation agreement and the new employer’s policy.

Can a business use a novated lease for a fleet

A novated lease is an employee benefit rather than ordinary business asset finance. Fleet purchasing often uses operating leases or chattel mortgages held by the business instead.

Disclaimer

This article provides general information only. It does not account for your objectives financial situation or needs. Tax treatment depends on individual circumstances and on legislation that can change. Seek independent advice from a qualified accountant tax agent or lawyer before acting on any information here.

More articles

Featured image for How Much Does It Cost to Start a Business in Queensland?
business-financestrategyfinancial

How Much Does It Cost to Start a Business in Queensland?

Starting a business in Queensland can be free at the very minimum, but most ventures need more than just an ABN and business name. This guide breaks down the mandatory government fees, including ABN, business name and company registration costs. It also explains the real-world expenses you should budget for, such as rent, equipment, staff, insurance and working capital. Use it to set a realistic first-year funding target.

21 November 2026 · 12 min read
Calculator and spreadsheet showing break-even point analysis with highlighted data.
business-financefinancial-advisory

Break-Even Point: Formula, Examples and Calculator

Discover a simple break even point calculator designed for Australian business owners. This tool shows you how many units must be sold and the revenue needed to cover fixed and variable costs. The post explains the formula and offers worked examples, practical guidance and a downloadable spreadsheet. It is an essential resource for setting clear sales targets and planning for business growth.

18 October 2026 · 12 min read
Elderly woman reviewing papers with a house model, considering a depreciation schedule.
accountingfinancialproperty

Is a Depreciation Schedule Worth It for an Old House?

A depreciation schedule can still deliver strong tax deductions on an older rental, but only if the property has eligible capital works or newer assets. This guide explains how construction date, renovations and report fees affect the result. It also shows why age alone does not decide eligibility. Learn how to weigh the likely tax saving against the cost before you order a report.

19 November 2026 · 10 min read

Schedule an appointment with an industry-specific expert

Simplifying finance for businesses, we handle the complexities. With EEA Advisory, you focus on your passion and we take care of your financial journey.

An EEA Advisory team member