Many investors ask whether ordering a depreciation schedule for an old rental house still makes sense. The honest answer is that it depends on the construction date, the scope of later renovations, the value of eligible assets and the fee charged by the quantity surveyor. An established property that contains qualifying capital works or newer plant and equipment can still return thousands of dollars in deductions over time, yet a pre-1985 cottage with no upgrades might yield almost nothing. This article explains how to make a confident yes or no decision before you spend a cent.
Short answer explained
Age alone never decides the outcome. A house built before the modern Division 43 start date may still include extensions, bathrooms, kitchens or structural improvements that attract the standard two-point-five per cent capital works deduction. Likewise, any new appliances or flooring that you install personally remain eligible under Division 40 despite the 2017 changes that restricted second-hand items. The real test compares the likely tax saving with the cost of the report. If the estimated benefit over your holding period exceeds the fee, a depreciation schedule is usually worthwhile. If not, you can save the money and stay compliant.
What is a property depreciation schedule
A depreciation schedule is a detailed report prepared by a registered quantity surveyor that allocates the historical construction cost of qualifying building works and the value of movable assets across their effective lives. Your accountant then plugs the yearly figures into the rental section of your tax return. The report often runs for forty years and covers both capital works under Division 43 and plant and equipment under Division 40. It gives you a defensible position in case the Australian Taxation Office reviews your claim and it saves you from estimating values yourself, which the ATO rarely accepts without evidence.
The three critical dates that determine eligibility
Construction and improvement dates create or remove entitlement to deductions. Three periods matter most for residential investors.
Before 18 July 1985
Original residential construction completed before this date usually attracts no Division 43 deduction. However, any later renovation that meets the after-15 September 1987 rules can still qualify. Many heritage cottages have had substantial makeovers over the past three decades, so investors should never assume that nothing is available without checking invoices or commissioning a professional inspection.
18 July 1985 to 15 September 1987
Capital works finished during this transitional window once qualified for four per cent deductions over twenty-five years. By the 2026 tax year, that entire deduction period has expired for most properties, so very little remains to claim. Only renovations or additions completed after the window will offer fresh Division 43 value.
After 15 September 1987
Residential construction and qualifying improvements completed from this date forward generally attract the two-point-five per cent deduction over forty years. If a house received an extension, a new brick garage or a major kitchen replacement in 2008, those costs still have more than twenty years of deductions remaining today. A depreciation schedule will identify and spread the balance correctly across future years.
What can still be claimed in an old house
Old never equals worthless. You can deduct qualifying renovations, structural improvements like concrete driveways, fences and retaining walls and any capital works paid for by previous owners that fall within the forty-year window. You can also claim new plant and equipment that you install yourself such as air conditioners, dishwashers, carpets, blinds and hot water systems. Even if the original builder’s allowance is long gone, these later items often produce first-year deductions that exceed the surveyor’s fee.
What may not be claimable
Original construction on very old dwellings usually sits outside Division 43. Likewise, second-hand ovens, washers, heaters and similar plant contained in a rental property that you purchased after the 2017 rule change cannot be claimed under Division 40. Private use portions, holiday home periods or works whose effective lives have fully run also fail the eligibility test. Recognising these limits stops unrealistic expectations and prevents costly audit adjustments.
Identifying when a schedule is likely to be worth the money
A depreciation report tends to pay for itself when the property was built after 1987, has undergone later renovations or holds new assets that you personally installed. If previous owners completed work that you cannot fully document, a quantity surveyor can estimate those costs using industry data. The schedule also becomes more attractive when you plan to keep the house in rental service for several years, because unused deductions roll forward annually until they are fully applied. Most importantly, you must expect the total deduction multiplied by your marginal tax rate to exceed the after-tax cost of the report.
Situations where a schedule may not stack up
Paying for a schedule can be uneconomic when a pre-1985 house shows no evidence of later qualifying work, has minimal replacement assets and is likely to be sold quickly. The same holds if the only plant in the property is second-hand and therefore excluded, or if the remaining Division 43 life is only a year or two. Although an inspection can still uncover surprises, many investors skip the report in these narrow cases and instead focus on other deductible items such as interest, repairs and management fees.
Comparison of typical old property scenarios
| Scenario | Division 43 balance | Division 40 potential | Likely outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pre-1985 build with no renovations | Nil | Minimal | Schedule often not justified |
| Pre-1985 build with 2000 kitchen and bathroom | Solid remaining balance | Some new assets | Schedule usually worthwhile |
| 1990 dwelling with limited upgrades | Twenty-plus years left | Second-hand assets only | Marginal outcome depends on construction cost |
| 1990 dwelling with 2018 extension and new appliances | Long remaining balance | Significant new assets | Strong case for schedule |
| 1986 dwelling now outside four per cent window | Expired | Depends on later work | Schedule value hinges on post-1987 improvements |
Worked example using a renovated pre-1985 home
Imagine a weatherboard house built in 1982 that you purchased for six hundred thousand dollars in early 2026. The selling agent mentioned a complete kitchen and bathroom renovation finished in 2009, plus an extension that added a master bedroom in 2012. After settlement, you installed a new reverse-cycle air conditioner for three thousand dollars and replaced the worn carpet for five thousand dollars. A quantity surveyor quotes eight hundred dollars for a comprehensive schedule.
The surveyor visits and estimates the qualifying renovation construction cost at one hundred and twenty thousand dollars. Under Division 43, you can claim two-point-five per cent of that amount each year while any of the forty-year period remains. For the 2026 year, fourteen years of the renovation life have already passed, leaving twenty-six years to go. The annual capital works deduction is three thousand dollars.
Next, the surveyor values your brand new air conditioner and carpet under Division 40. Both assets sit in depreciating asset pools at effective lives of ten and eight years respectively. Using the diminishing value method, the first-year combined deduction comes to two thousand two hundred dollars.
Total deduction for the first year equals five thousand two hundred dollars. At a marginal tax rate of thirty-seven per cent, your tax saving is approximately one thousand nine hundred and twenty-four dollars. The schedule fee of eight hundred dollars is fully deductible itself, worth an extra two hundred and ninety-six dollars in tax saved. Combined savings approach two thousand two hundred dollars in year one, almost triple the after-tax cost of the report. With twenty-five more years of Division 43 deductions plus ongoing Division 40 claims, the commercial case looks compelling.
Cost of a depreciation schedule in today’s market
Fees vary across providers, property types and locations but residential investors typically pay between six hundred and one thousand dollars for an individual house. Larger or architecturally complex dwellings can exceed two thousand while simple apartments often fall at the lower end. Rather than chasing the cheapest quote, focus on the provider’s qualifications, turnaround time and willingness to give a preliminary free estimate of likely deductions. Remember that the fee itself is a deductible expense in the year you pay it, softening the out-of-pocket impact.
Can an old house schedule be backdated
If you have owned an investment property for several years without claiming depreciation, you can usually start claiming from the current year onward as soon as you obtain a schedule. Amending prior returns may also be possible within the period allowed by the Taxation Administration Act, which is generally two or four years depending on circumstances. Seek specific advice from a registered tax agent before lodging any amendments, because the ATO applies strict time limits and documentation requirements.
Five practical steps before ordering
First confirm the original construction date and gather any council approvals, renovation invoices or building plans. Second, collect contracts or settlement statements that detail purchase price allocations, especially where a developer provided a new build warranty on an extension. Third, list assets that you personally installed such as appliances, curtains and flooring. Fourth, request a no-obligation quote or pre-assessment from at least one quantity surveyor, providing the information gathered so they can forecast potential deductions. Fifth, ask your accountant to translate the estimated deductions into a tax saving based on your ownership share and marginal rate. Completing these steps often clarifies whether the schedule will pay for itself long before you sign any engagement terms.
Final verdict for the main property categories
A very old dwelling with no qualifying improvements rarely produces enough depreciation to justify professional fees. Add even a modest renovation or a suite of new assets and the equation can flip quickly in favour of ordering a schedule. Post-1987 properties, and especially those with large extensions or recent upgrades, almost always present a strong case for engaging a quantity surveyor. By running the numbers and following the decision process outlined above, you can make an informed choice and avoid both missed deductions and unnecessary expenses.
Frequently asked questions
Is a depreciation schedule worth it for a house built before 1985
Sometimes it is. The deciding factor is whether the property includes qualifying renovations, structural improvements or new plant and equipment that fall within the current deduction rules.
Can I claim depreciation on an old investment property
Yes where eligible capital works or depreciating assets exist. Construction date, renovation history and the 2017 plant rules determine the final amount.
Can I claim renovations completed by the previous owner
Yes provided the work meets the Division 43 criteria and the forty-year deduction period has not expired. The remaining balance transfers to you on settlement.
Can I claim existing carpet, blinds or appliances
If those items were second-hand when you acquired the property after nine May 2017 they are generally excluded. Brand new replacements that you purchase can be claimed.
What is the difference between Division 43 and Division 40
Division 43 covers qualifying building construction and structural improvements. Division 40 covers movable plant and equipment such as appliances and floor coverings.
How much does a depreciation schedule cost in Australia
Most standalone houses fall in the six hundred to one thousand dollar range, with higher fees for premium or complex builds and lower fees for simple units.
Do I need a quantity surveyor
While legislation allows alternative evidence, the ATO specifically recognises quantity surveyors as suitably qualified to estimate construction costs. Engaging one reduces audit risk.
Is depreciation a tax refund
Depreciation is a deduction that reduces taxable income. The cash benefit equals the deduction multiplied by your marginal tax rate, not the deduction itself.
Should I arrange the schedule before or after renovating
Before renovating, photograph and document items you are about to remove. After renovations, update or obtain a new schedule so both removed and new assets are captured correctly.
Can I claim depreciation if I only rent the property part of the year
Yes, but you must apportion deductions based on the period the property was available for rent and exclude any private use days.
The information in this article is provided as a general guide only and does not constitute personal tax advice. Always consult a registered tax agent or quantity surveyor regarding your own circumstances.




